Closing Arguments End in Huawei Criminal Trial in Brooklyn as Jury Prepares to Deliberate
After two months of testimony, prosecutors told jurors Huawei ran a 20-year criminal enterprise, while the defense said the government put a 'sinister spin' on ordinary business and failed to prove its case. Deliberations are expected to begin Wednesday.
Closing arguments ended Tuesday in the criminal trial of Huawei in Brooklyn federal court, and the jury is expected to begin deliberations on Wednesday after hearing two sharply different accounts of the company’s business.
Prosecutors accuse Huawei of scheming to defraud HSBC and other banks about its business in Iran and conspiring to steal trade secrets from five American technology companies. The company was also indicted as a criminal enterprise. The trial began in September and heard from more than 60 prosecution witnesses and about 15 for the defense.

Two accounts of the same business
The government, in its closing statement on Monday, said prosecutors had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Huawei operated as a criminal enterprise. “For 20 years, Huawei committed a pattern of crimes targeted at American companies, the American financial system and the American government,” prosecutor Meredith Arfa said. “It is time to finally hold Huawei accountable.”
Defense lawyer Brian Heberlig told jurors on Tuesday that prosecutors had put a “sinister spin” on the company’s business activities and failed to prove the charges after two months of testimony. “They began with guilt and worked backwards,” Heberlig said. “When the evidence didn’t fit its theory, it moved the goal posts.”
Heberlig argued that the banks all knew Huawei operated in Iran, which is under American sanctions, and that they accepted the risk and competed for the company’s business. On the trade secrets charges, he said the government had “cherry-picked a handful of incidents” and tried to turn them into a 20-year conspiracy. “Huawei didn’t steal its way to success,” he said. “It earned it, plain and simple.”

A case that began in 2018
The case first made headlines in 2018, when Meng Wanzhou, Huawei’s chief financial officer and the daughter of its founder, was detained in Canada on an American warrant tied to the alleged bank fraud. She reached an agreement with prosecutors in 2021 and the charges against her were dismissed, but the case against the company dragged on.

The jury will deliver its verdict as tensions between the United States and China run high over artificial intelligence and amid a fragile trade truce between the two countries.
Reporting based on coverage by Reuters.