Index Funds vs. Target-Date Funds: Which One Fits Your Retirement Plan?
Index funds and target-date funds both offer low-cost, hands-off investing for retirement, but one leaves the mix in your hands while the other adjusts it for you.
An index fund and a target-date fund can look alike at first. Both charge far less than most actively managed funds, and both turn up in most 401(k) plans. The real difference is who manages the mix over time. With an index fund, that job is yours. With a target-date fund, the fund does it for you, on a schedule set by the year you plan to retire.
How an index fund works
An index fund buys the same securities as a market index, in the same proportions. A fund that tracks the S&P 500 holds shares of the 500 large U.S. companies in that index. If a company grows, its weight in the fund grows with it. If a company drops out of the index, the fund drops it too. No manager picks winners. The fund simply follows the index.

Because the work is mechanical, index funds run cheap. Broad U.S. stock index funds from large providers often charge 0.03 to 0.10 percent a year in expenses. The exact figure varies by provider and fund, and it changes over time. A single stock index fund holds only stocks, so most people pair it with a bond index fund and rebalance the mix themselves, once a year or so.
Index funds come in many kinds: funds that track the whole U.S. market, funds that track foreign stocks, funds that track bonds, and funds that track narrow slices such as small companies or real estate. The investor chooses the mix, and the mix stays put until the investor changes it.
How a target-date fund works
A target-date fund is named for a retirement year, such as 2055 or 2060. It holds a mix of stock funds and bond funds, and the mix changes as the target year gets closer. Early on, the fund may hold about 90 percent stocks. By the target year, the stock share falls to roughly half, and it keeps falling slowly after that. This set schedule is called the glide path.

Each provider sets its own glide path, so two funds with the same target year can hold different mixes. Some providers build the fund only from index funds, which keeps costs low. Others use actively managed funds, which cost more. Expense ratios for target-date funds often run from about 0.08 percent for index-based versions to 0.75 percent or more for actively managed versions. The exact figure varies by provider and changes over time.
The draw is simplicity. A worker picks the fund with the year closest to their planned retirement, puts money in, and never rebalances. The fund shifts the mix on its own. Many 401(k) plans use a target-date fund as the default choice for workers who do not pick investments.
Costs and control
The two funds differ most in cost and control. An index fund gives the investor full control over the mix and the lowest costs. A target-date fund charges more, in exchange for handling the mix and the rebalancing. The gap is small in dollars for an index-based target-date fund, and larger for an actively managed one.
Tax treatment is the same for both. Inside a 401(k) or IRA, gains are not taxed year to year. In a taxable account, both can pass along capital gains when the fund sells holdings, and target-date funds can pass along more, because they trade as the glide path shifts.

| Index fund | Target-date fund | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A fund that tracks a market index, such as the S&P 500 | A fund of funds built around a retirement year, with a mix that shifts over time |
| Who it suits | Investors who want to pick their own mix and rebalance it | Retirement savers who want one fund that handles the mix for them |
| Costs | Often 0.03 to 0.10 percent a year for broad stock index funds; the figure varies by provider and changes over time | Often 0.08 to 0.75 percent a year, lower for index-based versions; the figure varies by provider and changes over time |
| Pros | Lowest costs; full control over the mix; easy to pair with other funds | One fund covers the whole plan; automatic rebalancing; a common 401(k) default |
| Cons | The investor must rebalance and keep the mix on plan | Higher costs; glide paths differ by provider; less control over the mix |
The verdict
Choose an index fund if you want the lowest costs and you are willing to pick your own mix of stock and bond funds and rebalance it once a year. Choose a target-date fund if you want one fund that handles the mix for you and you are willing to pay a bit more for that.
The two are less different than the names suggest. A target-date fund is often built from index funds, so the choice is less about the funds themselves than about who manages the mix: you, or the fund. Either way, check the expense ratio and the glide path before you buy. Two funds with the same target year can hold different mixes, and a small difference in yearly cost adds up over decades.
Explainer based on fund descriptions published by Vanguard and Fidelity and on investor guidance published by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.